Higher Ed Chats
October 30th, 2024
17 minutes
Key Findings of the Enquiry Experience Tracker 2024
One in five inquiries still receives no response whatsoever. That number has held steady across the full research history of the Tracker, meaning a fifth of every marketing dollar spent on generating student interest disappears before anyone even picks up the conversation. Parsons is direct about it: "One in five inquiries still receive no response whatsoever. And that's not good enough." The finding points to a structural gap in how institutions manage their enrollment funnel, not a technology problem, but a process and prioritization one.
The study also quantifies something that's long been intuited but rarely measured: warmth works. When students received a warm, personalized response, only 1% reported a negative experience overall. When they didn't, that figure jumped to 25%. Students rated human interactions four times more positively than bot interactions, a finding that complicates the industry's growing appetite for automated inquiry handling. The temptation to scale through automation, Parsons notes, can come at the cost of the very conversion outcomes institutions are trying to improve.
On the geography front, 2024 showed uneven progress. The global tracker score rose four points, driven largely by gains in the UK and Australia/New Zealand, markets where lower pipeline volumes in 2024 made deeper individual engagement more feasible. The US and Canada are lagging, a pattern Parsons ties to both volume and process maturity. The conversation also addresses how immigration caps and shifting enrollment patterns in Australia and Canada are shaping the 2025 outlook, and what UK institutions are doing as their recovery continues.
The episode closes on the highest-leverage finding in the entire study: once a genuine two-way conversation is established, the likelihood of converting from offer to enrollment increases by a factor of three. Students engaging across multiple channels are twice as likely to convert. The implication for university recruitment strategies is clear. The biggest gains in student enrollment marketing don't come from more campaigns or better targeting. They come from what happens after the first inquiry arrives.
Who’s in the episode?
Jenni Parsons
Scott Miller is the host of Keystone Higher Ed Chats and the Executive Director of Keystone's international division, bringing over 11 years of EdTech experience to conversations about global education.
After graduating from DePauw University, living and working in different cultures showed him that stepping outside your comfort zone doesn't just broaden your horizons; it reshapes them entirely. That belief in the transformative power of international experiences brought Scott to Keystone in 2010, where he's spent over a decade (and counting) helping higher education institutions reach students worldwide.
On Keystone Higher Ed Chats, Scott speaks with thought-leaders in the industry about what he's most passionate about: how education changes lives, how cultural experiences broaden perspectives at any age, and how Keystone's mission—connecting students with their ideal higher education institution—makes those life-changing moments possible.
Timestamps & Takeaways
Timestamps
00:03
Introduction: Scott Miller welcomes Jenni Parsons, Chief Market and Partnerships Officer at UniQuest
02:43
Study methodology: 102 institutions, 10 countries, 44 criteria, 6 inquiry channels
05:01
Human vs. bot: students rate human interactions 4x more positively
05:01
The warmth variable: 1% negative sentiment for warm responses vs. 25% for cold
07:00
2024 global tracker results: overall score up 4 points, regional breakdown
07:19
Award spotlight: Kingston University recognized for phone inquiry performance
09:42
Practical recommendations: the five actions institutions can take right now
10:00
The non-response problem: 1 in 5 inquiries still receive no reply
10:30
The follow-up gap: 1 in 5 students who get a response receive no follow-up
11:00
Conversion data: two-way conversation increases offer-to-enroll conversion by 3x
11:00
Multi-channel engagement doubles student likelihood to convert
12:00
2025 outlook: immigration caps, market shifts, and what to watch
22:45
The resilience case: prestige, academic freedom, and global draw
23:51
Closing: what institutions should do now
Takeaways
1 in 5 inquiries go unanswered — audit your response rate now
Twenty percent of student inquiries receive no response at all, a figure that's held steady across the full history of the Enquiry Experience Tracker. As Jenni Parsons put it: "One in five inquiries still receive no response whatsoever. And that's not good enough." For any institution spending on marketing to generate student interest, a 20% non-response rate is direct erosion of that budget. The first step is pulling your inquiry data and understanding where the drop-off happens before it can be fixed.
Warm responses cut negative sentiment from 25% down to 1%
Tone isn't soft, it's measurable. When students received a warm response to their inquiry, only 1% reported an overall negative experience. When the response was cold or impersonal, that figure jumped to 25%. That's a 24-point swing in student perception based on nothing more than how staff communicate. Training admissions and recruitment teams to write warmer, more human replies is one of the highest-return investments an institution can make.
Students prefer humans over chatbots by a 4-to-1 margin
The 2024 tracker found students rated their interactions with humans four times more positively than their interactions with bots. This doesn't mean chatbots have no place in inquiry management, but it does mean institutions that have fully automated first contact are likely creating a poor first impression. If bot-handling is necessary for capacity reasons, it's worth auditing whether a human handoff can happen earlier in the conversation.
Two-way conversation triples your offer-to-enroll conversion rate
Once a genuine back-and-forth dialogue is established with a prospective student, the likelihood of converting from offer to enrollment increases by roughly 3x. This isn't about sending more emails; it's about creating actual dialogue. Inquiry workflows should be designed to invite responses, not just deliver information. A follow-up message asking a specific question gets much further than a broadcast update.
Multi-channel engagement doubles conversion — don't default to email only
Students who receive outreach across more than one channel are twice as likely to convert. Yet many institutions default to email alone, leaving phone, SMS, and social touchpoints largely unused after the initial inquiry. Mapping out which channels your prospective students actually use, and building your follow-up sequences to reach them there, is a practical and data-backed way to improve yield.
A quarter of responding institutions still don't follow up
Getting a response out is only half the job. The tracker found that 1 in 5 students who received a response got no subsequent follow-up. For institutions that have already done the hard work of building inquiry response processes, this is a gap worth closing quickly. A simple follow-up sequence, even just one or two touchpoints after the initial reply, is enough to move students further through the funnel.
The UK and ANZ score gains show what's possible with individual attention
The 2024 global tracker score rose 4 points, driven largely by improvements in the UK and Australia/New Zealand. Jenni Parsons attributed those gains in part to lower pipeline volumes in 2024, which gave teams more capacity to engage students individually rather than at scale. For institutions in markets where volume pressure is high, that connection is worth examining: what's the minimum viable process change that preserves some of that one-to-one quality?
You may also like
How the Trump Administration is Reshaping Higher Education
One year into the Trump administration, U.S. higher education looks different in ways that aren't fully visible yet. This episode of Higher Ed Chats brings in Sarah Brown and Rick Seltzer, both senior journalists at The Chronicle of Higher Education, to take stock of what's actually changed, what's still playing out, and what it means for higher education...
Let’s talk
Keystone’s team of experts can create a digital marketing strategy
that aligns with your student recruitment and enrollment goals.
Schedule a call with our experts.